Projects

Italian Journalism in the Age of Silvio Berlusconi

What's happened to Italian news media in the last two decades, and what was it like before?

Reporting China

Chinese journalism after market reforms: the possibility and dangers of investigation.

Russian News is Good News

The remaking of Russian journalism, and Russian journalists, in the age of Vladimir Putin.

Independent Journalism in Post-Independence States

The perils and possibilities of holding power to account in different African countries.

The Pipers and the Tunes

A comparative perspective on the power of proprietors, public service and people to influence the content and limits of journalism.

The Peripheral Vision of Central Issues

How good is the coverage of matters essential to public welfare and the public interest? And who cares about it?

Beppe Grillo in Oxford

Beppe Grillo in Oxford

A discussion on Beppe Grillo as demagogue, political activist and comedian.

Beppe Grillo, the Italian comic, social activist and blogger, came to Oxford* – sponsored by the Axess Programme and the Italian Studies at Oxford network – and gave an audience of about 400 a (free) exposure to a show which crosses the lines between comedy, satire, social comment and a civic call to arms. Among Europe’s most popular bloggers, he’s built on his wit and stage presence a movement whose main aim – through “Vaffanculo” (or “fuck off”) days – seeks to have removed from the parliament those members who have criminal convictions. Grillo spoke in Italian: that limited the event to - mainly – the Italian scholarly community, students and teachers, in Oxford: but they still filled a sizable hall in the Taylorian Institute.

The event was chaired, if it can be so described, by David Forgacs, professor of Italian at University College London, and me. We put some questions to him at first: he began to answer them, sitting in a little panel with us on the stage – but soon segued into his act, rising, then using the stage for a kind of ballet, as his comic persona as a simple man oppressed, outraged and astounded by the follies of his country convulses his body and loses his tongue into a flood – half protest, half comedy.

Grillo hates the Italian press: our original proposal, that one of the panellists should be my friend Enrico Franceschini, Repubblica’s London bureau chief and a novelist, was refused. He hates it, he says, because it takes political subsidies (which is true); because if doesn’t adequately oppose the Italian political system to which, he believes, it is too closely linked; and ignores him. The one image he showed in his act was a picture, on the front page of the Turin daily La Stampa, of him addressing a meeting: the picture was cropped so that it seemed as though he was talking to an equestrian statue on a plinth across from his platform: widened, it showed the Turin piazza packed with people.

A flavour of the man and his campaigns can be got from his website – including that in English. Three things to say of him as a media figure:

First, he’s something of what his opponents say of him: he’s a demagogue. The satirist Daniele Lutazzi, in a 2007 article in Micromega, said of his style that, “Se parli alla pancia, certo che riempi le piazze, ma non è democrazia dal basso: è flash mobbing” (“If you speak to the gut, you can surely fill the squares: but that’s not democracy from below, it’s flash-mobbing”). Grillo doesnt differentiate: politicians of the left as are as bad as the right – though he did, at least for a time, endorse the Italia dei Valori party of  Antonio di Pietro. And newspapers as poisonous as the present Giornale are put on the same plane as Repubblica, which has kept up a constant pressure on the Prime Minister to respond to questions about his political and personal deportment last year.

Second, he’s been among the most successful of political activists in constructing his own alternative network – though website, appearances, rallies and organisation of alternative structures. He’s also drawn huge attention, national and international, to the more glaring horrors of Italian political life. He has not succeeded in subtantially damaging the Berlusconi government: but nor has the left opposition.

And third, he’s a great comedian. Humour, as a legion of satirists and comics have discovered in the past decade, is not just a political weapon, it’s a means of seeing politics. This is a movement of very great importance: it’s still not clear how much it contributed to democratic engagement and good government; but it’s fun.

 

*Photos and podcast of the Oxford event to be uploaded shortly.

We invite our readers to submit blogs similar to those posted on the website by our researchers. If you have strong views about journalism and politics that you'd like to share, submit your writing to us by emailing janice.winter@axessjournalism.com


Comments (2)

Dear Mr. Lloyd,
I can subscribe almost entirely what you have written about B. Grillo. D. Luttazzi, in my opinion has half reason. Who speaks to the gut, in Italy is first the running goverment. Parties as Lega Nord - against extra CE, clandestines, Islam People - and PDL - safety, through deployment of police? Better school, through deployment of teachers? better public service, through attacking supposed drone personnel?. Maybe Luttazzi is right, but in an intellectual way. Italian people has loose any intellectual appeal. And so that's why those demagogic policy by the governement is so successful in Italy. So I think it's better to set the "Grillo's gut speech" against actual "gut speech" by the government. Of course the matter is the improve the capacity of Italians to be more conscious. I don't know if Grillo will succeed in this, anyway I call for an urgent stream of consciousness which is missing here, in this deseased country. Last summer I met a Danish family during vacancies in Greece and I asked them "Please come in Italy and save us!". They responded "only you italians can save your country". And they where right. The democratic - not demagogic - movement borne starting from Grillo may be that saving army which is deeply needed here.

Posted by Sidney Sonnino on February 1, 2010 - 3:28 PM

ERRATA CORRIGE
Excuse me, in comment n°1 I wrote the word "deployment".
I ment "Decreament".
Apologies
Sidney

Posted by Sidney Sonnino on February 1, 2010 - 3:40 PM


Post a Comment

Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

(required)

(required)

Notify me on new comments