Projects

Italian Journalism in the Age of Silvio Berlusconi

What's happened to Italian news media in the last two decades, and what was it like before?

Reporting China

Chinese journalism after market reforms: the possibility and dangers of investigation.

Russian News is Good News

The remaking of Russian journalism, and Russian journalists, in the age of Vladimir Putin.

Independent Journalism in Post-Independence States

The perils and possibilities of holding power to account in different African countries.

The Pipers and the Tunes

A comparative perspective on the power of proprietors, public service and people to influence the content and limits of journalism.

The Peripheral Vision of Central Issues

How good is the coverage of matters essential to public welfare and the public interest? And who cares about it?

A greener grass

A greener grass

The attention of the Italian media to everything which is published on the British press suggests more than simple open-mindedness.

There was no shortage of attention for Italy in the world's newspapers over the last week. Last Friday, The Economist published an article outlining the difficulties Berlusconi is facing on the domestic front. Even more controversial proved to be the editorial which came out on the same issue of the weekly, suggesting that it is time to say addio to the Italian PM. Last Sunday, the Financial Times then added more misery to the PM, by publishing an editorial, Berlusconi at bay, in which it criticised the fact that Berlusconi was spending more and more time on his own businesses rather than on, for example, addressing the challenges connected to the economic crisis.

The articles produced two types of reactions in Italy. These are the same ones emerging whenever well-known media, such as the FT or The Economist, publish stories about Italian politics and, in particular, on Berlusconi. Unsurprisingly, the left-leaning La Repubblica gave ample space to the articles which proved to be so critical of the Prime Minister.  Conversely, on the right-leaning Il Giornale, an article appeared which blamed the British gufi (owls, to signify that they bring bad luck) for not understanding anything about Italy.

Despite the differences in their contents, both articles show the ample space Italian newspapers always dedicate to the coverage of Italian politics made around the world, and particularly by the British media. In the case of La Repubblica article, this attention can be motivated as a way to outline how the Italian newspaper’s opinion is supported by other authoritative sources. For Il Giornale, instead, it is a way of recreating a certain patriotic sentiment, based on the idea that foreigners will never understand Italy (and, anyway, they would not want the good of Italy).

This obsessive attention with the foreign press may simply be showing that Italy is a country with an understandable, natural tendency to look outside of its borders, given its attachment to the European Union and, more generally, its economic and political interconnections with the rest of the world. In this respect, the attention to what the foreign media say is completely legitimate and totally justified. However, one wonders whether there may be something else in play. Perhaps, this may suggest a certain lack of confidence of the Italian media, who may suffer from that very Italian sentiment that the neighbour’s grass is always greener and, hence, always worth at least talking about.

We invite our readers to submit blogs similar to those posted on the website by our researchers. If you have strong views about journalism and politics that you'd like to share, submit your writing to us by emailing janice.winter@axessjournalism.com


Comments (1)

I definitely agree. I used to read a review called 'Internazionale' where I could find many translated articles from the main newspapers of all the countries, and therefore make up for the lack of information about what was happening in the world I felt. Recently, the review has started to be more involved in how Italy was considered abroad. Most of the times, I had to read articles (often from The Guardian) full of disapproval towards Italians who kept on voting for Berlusconi, as if talking about Italy would mean just this. The review itself showed to indirectly agree and express its point through them.
I think consider foreign press' opinion about our affairs is a clear and good sign of care and attention, but this should coincide with as much interest from us as from them, whereas I think this is not what our press does. Looking abroad for support make me feel quite sad, because I do not see why we should need to strenghten our positions using other ones, besides coming from different societies with dissimilar structures, histories and situations.
"That very Italian sentiment that the neighbour's grass is always greener" is in my opinion increased by this propensity; sometimes I even wonder if to make us less confident is just their aim.

Posted by Giulia Roverato on Janurary 6, 2010 - 5:02 PM


Post a Comment

Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

(required)

(required)

Notify me on new comments